PDA

View Full Version : Atrocities in Iraq: 'I killed innocent people for our government'


Bobenis
06-09-2004, 07:46 PM
This is truly sad and disgusting! Goes to show us all what is happening and the cover ups and lies we are all fed as a result. It's LONG but so worth the read everyone. :Crying






Atrocities in Iraq: 'I killed innocent people for our government'
By Paul Rockwell -- Special to The Bee
Published 2:15 am PDT Sunday, May 16, 2004

"We forget what war is about, what it does to those who wage it and those who suffer from it. Those who hate war the most, I have often found, are veterans who know it.

For nearly 12 years, Staff Sgt. Jimmy Massey was a hard-core, some say gung-ho, Marine. For three years he trained fellow Marines in one of the most grueling indoctrination rituals in military life - Marine boot camp.
The Iraq war changed Massey. The brutality, the sheer carnage of the U.S. invasion, touched his conscience and transformed him forever. He was honorably discharged with full severance last Dec. 31 and is now back in his hometown, Waynsville, N.C.

When I talked with Massey last week, he expressed his remorse at the civilian loss of life in incidents in which he himself was involved.

Q: You spent 12 years in the Marines. When were you sent to Iraq?

A: I went to Kuwait around Jan. 17. I was in Iraq from the get-go. And I was involved in the initial invasion.

Q: What does the public need to know about your experiences as a Marine?

A: The cause of the Iraqi revolt against the American occupation. What they need to know is we killed a lot of innocent people. I think at first the Iraqis had the understanding that casualties are a part of war. But over the course of time, the occupation hurt the Iraqis. And I didn't see any humanitarian support.

Q: What experiences turned you against the war and made you leave the Marines?

A: I was in charge of a platoon that consists of machine gunners and missile men. Our job was to go into certain areas of the towns and secure the roadways. There was this one particular incident - and there's many more - the one that really pushed me over the edge. It involved a car with Iraqi civilians. From all the intelligence reports we were getting, the cars were loaded down with suicide bombs or material. That's the rhetoric we received from intelligence. They came upon our checkpoint. We fired some warning shots. They didn't slow down. So we lit them up.

Q: Lit up? You mean you fired machine guns?

A: Right. Every car that we lit up we were expecting ammunition to go off. But we never heard any. Well, this particular vehicle we didn't destroy completely, and one gentleman looked up at me and said: "Why did you kill my brother? We didn't do anything wrong." That hit me like a ton of bricks.

Q: He spoke English?

A: Oh, yeah.

Q: Baghdad was being bombed. The civilians were trying to get out, right?

A: Yes. They received pamphlets, propaganda we dropped on them. It said, "Just throw up your hands, lay down weapons." That's what they were doing, but we were still lighting them up. They weren't in uniform. We never found any weapons.

Q: You got to see the bodies and casualties?

A: Yeah, firsthand. I helped throw them in a ditch.

Q: Over what period did all this take place?

A: During the invasion of Baghdad.


'We lit him up pretty good'
Q: How many times were you involved in checkpoint "light-ups"?
A: Five times. There was [the city of] Rekha. The gentleman was driving a stolen work utility van. He didn't stop. With us being trigger happy, we didn't really give this guy much of a chance. We lit him up pretty good. Then we inspected the back of the van. We found nothing. No explosives.

Q: The reports said the cars were loaded with explosives. In all the incidents did you find that to be the case?

A: Never. Not once. There were no secondary explosions. As a matter of fact, we lit up a rally after we heard a stray gunshot.

Q: A demonstration? Where?

A: On the outskirts of Baghdad. Near a military compound. There were demonstrators at the end of the street. They were young and they had no weapons. And when we rolled onto the scene, there was already a tank that was parked on the side of the road. If the Iraqis wanted to do something, they could have blown up the tank. But they didn't. They were only holding a demonstration. Down at the end of the road, we saw some RPGs (rocket-propelled grenades) lined up against the wall. That put us at ease because we thought: "Wow, if they were going to blow us up, they would have done it."

Q: Were the protest signs in English or Arabic?

A: Both.

Q: Who gave the order to wipe the demonstrators out?

A: Higher command. We were told to be on the lookout for the civilians because a lot of the Fedayeen and the Republican Guards had tossed away uniforms and put on civilian clothes and were mounting terrorist attacks on American soldiers. The intelligence reports that were given to us were basically known by every member of the chain of command. The rank structure that was implemented in Iraq by the chain of command was evident to every Marine in Iraq. The order to shoot the demonstrators, I believe, came from senior government officials, including intelligence communities within the military and the U.S. government.

Q: What kind of firepower was employed?

A: M-16s, 50-cal. machine guns.

Q: You fired into six or ten kids? Were they all taken out?

A: Oh, yeah. Well, I had a "mercy" on one guy. When we rolled up, he was hiding behind a concrete pillar. I saw him and raised my weapon up, and he put up his hands. He ran off. I told everybody, "Don't shoot." Half of his foot was trailing behind him. So he was running with half of his foot cut off.

Q: After you lit up the demonstration, how long before the next incident?

A: Probably about one or two hours. This is another thing, too. I am so glad I am talking with you, because I suppressed all of this.

Q: Well, I appreciate you giving me the information, as hard as it must be to recall the painful details.

A: That's all right. It's kind of therapy for me. Because it's something that I had repressed for a long time.

Q: And the incident?

A: There was an incident with one of the cars. We shot an individual with his hands up. He got out of the car. He was badly shot. We lit him up. I don't know who started shooting first. One of the Marines came running over to where we were and said: "You all just shot a guy with his hands up." Man, I forgot about this.


Depleted uranium and cluster bombs
Q: You mention machine guns. What can you tell me about cluster bombs, or depleted uranium?
A: Depleted uranium. I know what it does. It's basically like leaving plutonium rods around. I'm 32 years old. I have 80 percent of my lung capacity. I ache all the time. I don't feel like a healthy 32-year-old.

Q: Were you in the vicinity of of depleted uranium?

A: Oh, yeah. It's everywhere. DU is everywhere on the battlefield. If you hit a tank, there's dust.

Q: Did you breath any dust?

A: Yeah.

Q: And if DU is affecting you or our troops, it's impacting Iraqi civilians.

A: Oh, yeah. They got a big wasteland problem.

Q: Do Marines have any precautions about dealing with DU?

A: Not that I know of. Well, if a tank gets hit, crews are detained for a little while to make sure there are no signs or symptoms. American tanks have depleted uranium on the sides, and the projectiles have DU in them. If an enemy vehicle gets hit, the area gets contaminated. Dead rounds are in the ground. The civilian populace is just now starting to learn about it. Hell, I didn't even know about DU until two years ago. You know how I found out about it? I read an article in Rolling Stone magazine. I just started inquiring about it, and I said "Holy s---!"

Q: Cluster bombs are also controversial. U.N. commissions have called for a ban. Were you acquainted with cluster bombs?

A: I had one of my Marines in my battalion who lost his leg from an ICBM.

Q: What's an ICBM?

A: A multi-purpose cluster bomb.

Q: What happened?

A: He stepped on it. We didn't get to training about clusters until about a month before I left.

Q: What kind of training?

A: They told us what they looked like, and not to step on them.

Q: Were you in any areas where they were dropped?

A: Oh, yeah. They were everywhere.

Q: Dropped from the air?

A: From the air as well as artillery.

Q: Are they dropped far away from cities, or inside the cities?

A: They are used everywhere. Now if you talked to a Marine artillery officer, he would give you the runaround, the politically correct answer. But for an average grunt, they're everywhere.

Q: Including inside the towns and cities?

A: Yes, if you were going into a city, you knew there were going to be ICBMs.

Q: Cluster bombs are anti-personnel weapons. They are not precise. They don't injure buildings, or hurt tanks. Only people and living things. There are a lot of undetonated duds and they go off after the battles are over.

A: Once the round leaves the tube, the cluster bomb has a mind of its own. There's always human error. I'm going to tell you: The armed forces are in a tight spot over there. It's starting to leak out about the civilian casualties that are taking place. The Iraqis know. I keep hearing reports from my Marine buddies inside that there were 200-something civilians killed in Fallujah. The military is scrambling right now to keep the raps on that. My understanding is Fallujah is just littered with civilian bodies.


Embedded reporters
Q: How are the embedded reporters responding?
A: I had embedded reporters in my unit, not my platoon. One we had was a South African reporter. He was scared s---less. We had an incident where one of them wanted to go home.

Q: Why?

A: It was when we started going into Baghdad. When he started seeing the civilian casualties, he started wigging out a little bit. It didn't start until we got on the outskirts of Baghdad and started taking civilian casualties.

Q: I would like to go back to the first incident, when the survivor asked why did you kill his brother. Was that the incident that pushed you over the edge, as you put it?

A: Oh, yeah. Later on I found out that was a typical day. I talked with my commanding officer after the incident. He came up to me and says: "Are you OK?" I said: "No, today is not a good day. We killed a bunch of civilians." He goes: "No, today was a good day." And when he said that, I said "Oh, my goodness, what the hell am I into?"

Q: Your feelings changed during the invasion. What was your state of mind before the invasion?

A: I was like every other troop. My president told me they got weapons of mass destruction, that Saddam threatened the free world, that he had all this might and could reach us anywhere. I just bought into the whole thing.

Q: What changed you?

A: The civilian casualties taking place. That was what made the difference. That was when I changed.

Q: Did the revelations that the government fabricated the evidence for war affect the troops?

A: Yes. I killed innocent people for our government. For what? What did I do? Where is the good coming out of it? I feel like I've had a hand in some sort of evil lie at the hands of our government. I just feel embarrassed, ashamed about it.


Showdown with superiors
Q: I understand that all the incidents - killing civilians at checkpoints, itchy fingers at the rally - weigh on you. What happened with your commanding officers? How did you deal with them?
A: There was an incident. It was right after the fall of Baghdad, when we went back down south. On the outskirts of Karbala, we had a morning meeting on the battle plan. I was not in a good mindset. All these things were going through my head - about what we were doing over there. About some of the things my troops were asking. I was holding it all inside. My lieutenant and I got into a conversation. The conversation was striking me wrong. And I lashed out. I looked at him and told him: "You know, I honestly feel that what we're doing is wrong over here. We're committing genocide."

He asked me something and I said that with the killing of civilians and the depleted uranium we're leaving over here, we're not going to have to worry about terrorists. He didn't like that. He got up and stormed off. And I knew right then and there that my career was over. I was talking to my commanding officer.

Q: What happened then?

A: After I talked to the top commander, I was kind of scurried away. I was basically put on house arrest. I didn't talk to other troops. I didn't want to hurt them. I didn't want to jeopardize them.

I want to help people. I felt strongly about it. I had to say something. When I was sent back to stateside, I went in front of the sergeant major. He's in charge of 3,500-plus Marines. "Sir," I told him, "I don't want your money. I don't want your benefits. What you did was wrong."

It was just a personal conviction with me. I've had an impeccable career. I chose to get out. And you know who I blame? I blame the president of the U.S. It's not the grunt. I blame the president because he said they had weapons of mass destruction. It was a lie.

Maro
06-09-2004, 07:54 PM
I can predict the response to this :Roll Eyes

sadly in any war there will be people like this

:Nope

egarrard
06-09-2004, 07:55 PM
And this proves what? That someone found another future Presidential candidate?

bejohnson
06-09-2004, 08:11 PM
That's why it's called the horrors of war. There is nothing clean, neat or by the book in war. If war was as clean and precise as the opposition wants it to be we would have a war every year.

Welcome to the real world. Nothing in Iraq can compare to the innocent deaths in WWI and WWII. Read about the fire bombings of Tokyo and the almost nightly attacks on London and Germany. Do some research into the Dresden firebombing and the resultant destruction and loss of civilian life.

Read the complete history of the holocaust and what happened after the allied soldiers discovered the concentration camps. No war is desirable or sane but almost everyone is necessary. Iraq is a walk in the park on Saturday afternoon compared to those examples.

Powderboy
06-09-2004, 08:23 PM
on an opposite note.....

Subject: A Real Hero SOMETHING THAT DIDN'T MAKE THE NEWS

Maybe you'd like to hear about something other than ***** Reservists and naked Iraqis.

Maybe you'd like to hear about a real American, somebody who honored the uniform he wears.

Meet Brian Chontosh.

Churchville-Chili Central School class of 1991. Proud graduate of the Rochester Institute of Technology.

Husband and about-to-be father. First lieutenant in the United States Marine Corps.

And a genuine hero.

The secretary of the Navy said so yesterday.

At 29 Palms in California Brian Chontosh was presented with the Navy Cross, the second highest award for combat bravery the United States can bestow.

That's a big deal.

But you won't see it on the network news tonight, and all you read in Brian's hometown newspaper was two paragraphs of nothing. Instead, it was more blather about some mental defective MPs who acted like animals.

The odd fact about the American media in this war is that it's not covering the American military. The most plugged-in nation in the world is receiving virtually no true information about what its warriors are doing.

Oh, sure, there's a body count. We know how many Americans have fallen. And we see those same casket pictures day in and day out. And we're almost on a first-name basis with the pukes who abused the Iraqi prisoners. And we know all about improvised explosive devices and how we lost Fallujah and what Arab public-opinion polls say about us and how the world hates us.

We get a non-stop feed of gloom and doom.

But we don't hear about the heroes.

The incredibly brave GIs who honorably do their duty. The ones our grandparents would have carried on their shoulders down Fifth Avenue.

The ones we completely ignore.

Like Brian Chontosh.

It was a year ago on the march into Baghdad. Brian Chontosh was a platoon leader rolling up Highway 1 in a humvee.

When all hell broke loose.

Ambush city.

The young Marines were being cut to ribbons. Mortars, machine guns, rocket propelled grenades. And the id out of Churchville was in charge. It was do or die and it was up to him.

So he moved to the side of his column, looking for a way to lead his men to safety. As he tried to poke a hole through the Iraqi line his humvee came under direct enemy machine gun fire.

It was fish in a barrel and the Marines were the fish.

And Brian Chontosh gave the order to attack. He told his driver to floor the humvee directly at the machine gun emplacement that was firing at them. And he had the guy on top with the .50 cal unload on them.

Within moments there were Iraqis slumped across the machine gun and Chontosh was still advancing, ordering his driver now to take the humvee directly into the Iraqi trench that was attacking his Marines. Over into the battlement the humvee went and out the door Brian Chontosh bailed, carrying an M16 and a Beretta and 228 years of Marine Corps pride.

And he ran down the trench.

With its mortars and riflemen, machineguns and grenadiers.

And he killed them all.

He fought with the M16 until he was out of ammo. Then he fought with the Beretta until it was out of ammo. Then he picked up a dead man's AK47 and fought with that until it was out of ammo. Then he picked up another dead man's AK47 and fought with that until it was out of ammo.

At one point he even fired a discarded Iraqi RPG into an enemy cluster, sending attackers flying with its grenade explosion.

When he was done Brian Chontosh had cleared 200 yards of entrenched Iraqis from his platoon's flank. He had killed more than 20 and wounded at least as many more.

But that's probably not how he would tell it.

He would probably merely say that his Marines were in trouble, and he got them out of trouble. Hoo-ah, and drive on.

"By his outstanding display of decisive leadership, unlimited courage in the face of heavy enemy fire, and utmost devotion to duty, 1st Lt. Chontosh reflected great credit upon himself and upheld the highest traditions of the Marine Corps and the United States Naval Service."

That's what the citation says.

And that's what nobody will hear.

That's what doesn't seem to be making the evening news. Accounts of American valor are dismissed by the press as propaganda, yet accounts of American difficulties are heralded as objectivity. It makes you wonder if the role of the media is to inform, or to depress - to report or to deride. To tell the truth, or to feed us lies.

But I guess it doesn't matter.

We're going to turn out all right.

As long as men like Brian Chontosh wear our uniform.

Bobenis
06-09-2004, 08:59 PM
That's why it's called the horrors of war. There is nothing clean, neat or by the book in war. If war was as clean and precise as the opposition wants it to be we would have a war every year.

Welcome to the real world. Nothing in Iraq can compare to the innocent deaths in WWI and WWII. Read about the fire bombings of Tokyo and the almost nightly attacks on London and Germany. Do some research into the Dresden firebombing and the resultant destruction and loss of civilian life.

Read the complete history of the holocaust and what happened after the allied soldiers discovered the concentration camps. No war is desirable or sane but almost everyone is necessary. Iraq is a walk in the park on Saturday afternoon compared to those examples.

I realize that man, but it does not make it any better however. 1 innocent or a 1000, it's all wrong. Innocents died in WWII for a REAL war, a world war that threatened the entire planet with a dictatorial dominance. Not a bogus war fought for money and oil covered by a blanket of lies though. Yes, Saddam needed to be wiped out but why wasn't he 13 years ago...mmmm. There are reasons unseen on that subject. Innocent lives lost has no less or more justification regardless, but for a bogus war...well. Don't forget the Polish at the hands of Stalin..more died in that turmoil than Jews did in the holocaust.

This article above however was described as higher command almost enjoying themselves and saying it's good to kill unarmed, harmless civilians. That is NOT acceptable! This is all lead by bogus info given to these unaware soliders to do the rediculous dirty work for their superiors and the govt, while they sit back in some comfortable locale and relax. Slaughtering innocent children?!?! Seeing first hand as you raise your gun and shoot at kids? That is acceptable? Not being informed about DU? It's a prime example of re-education and indoctrination. They are told nothing as their lives are but just a number (tags) to the govt. I am not disagreeing with you but I am sorry to say I can't relax and accept this and go "oh well." I just can't. It is sad and little is know about this in the US or anywhere else for that matter as it's all hush hush. Just like Vietnam all over again, only this time we can't watch it while we eat dinner...thankfully.

bejohnson
06-09-2004, 09:11 PM
Give the war for oil a rest. Check this thread (http://www.3dgameman.com/forums/showthread.php?t=25483) for the latest on the Iraqi oil control.

Artcwolf
06-09-2004, 09:17 PM
Another Iraq war thread? There are a lot of productive topics out there why does this one keep showing up?

egarrard
06-09-2004, 09:19 PM
Yes, Saddam needed to be wiped out but why wasn't he 13 years ago...mmmm.Because of the restrictions put on by the UN, not some imagined war-for-oil nonsense. You sure go on about stuff you know nothing about. Or very little about, at least.

egarrard
06-09-2004, 09:20 PM
Another Iraq war thread? There are a lot of productive topics out there why does this one keep showing up?Hatred and jealousy, most likely. :(

wazman
06-09-2004, 09:48 PM
Hatred and jealousy, most likely. :(

I'm only making an observation. But it seems that when bejohnson posts these kinds of threads, it's fine. But when Bobenis does it, it's hatred and jealousy.

That's my observation.

Bobenis
06-09-2004, 10:29 PM
Of course. Because these people point out something about someone else who they actually hate themselves. Admitting ones own weaknesses and issues, to themselves, makes them look weak. Therefore blame hatred on someone else, when in fact they realize it is their own bad qualities which they hate. No worries. Hate is a strong and harsh word but for some, it rolls off the tongue with ease. Jealousy...now I am lost on that one? Jealous of not being able to kill some children? What is the jealousy about? I wish those who pointed fingers, would back up their rediculous accusations...

It is a great article from someone who was there and went throught it all. He has a right to tell it and voice his sorrow. I felt it was touching and compelling and decided to share it. I meant no harm nor arousing "hatred", only a touch on the real side on a US solider who has seen what we can only imagine but would never want to experience.

egarrard
06-09-2004, 10:32 PM
I'm only making an observation. But it seems that when bejohnson posts these kinds of threads, it's fine. But when Bobenis does it, it's hatred and jealousy.

That's my observation.Because Ed doesn't post them to denigrate anything, just educate and inform. When he has posted something questionable, I've called him on it. For example, the bogus quote from the Quran.

wazman
06-09-2004, 10:35 PM
I'll just let it lie there.

egarrard
06-09-2004, 10:38 PM
Of course. Because these people point out something about someone else who they actually hate themselves. Admitting ones own weaknesses and issues, to themselves, makes them look weak. Therefore blame hatred on someone else, when in fact they realize it is their own bad qualities which they hate. No worries. Hate is a strong and harsh word but for some, it rolls off the tongue with ease. Jealousy...now I am lost on that one? Jealous of not being able to kill some children? What is the jealousy about? I wish those who pointed fingers, would back up their rediculous accusations...

It is a great article from someone who was there and went throught it all. He has a right to tell it and voice his sorrow. I felt it was touching and compelling and decided to share it. I meant no harm nor arousing "hatred", only a touch on the real side on a US solider who has seen what we can only imagine but would never want to experience.I hate the lies and half-truths you've fallen into. When you posted something factual, I have agreed with you. It's not the people I'm annoyed by, just the misinformation and propoganda presented as fact. Like the statement about the first Gulf War. I wasn't in my early teens at that time. I remember what happened and why.

Bobenis
06-09-2004, 11:22 PM
I hate the lies and half-truths you've fallen into. When you posted something factual, I have agreed with you. It's not the people I'm annoyed by, just the misinformation and propoganda presented as fact. Like the statement about the first Gulf War. I wasn't in my early teens at that time. I remember what happened and why.


OK...and? You have me lost on bringing up the Gulf War but how can you call this soldiers experiences lies? Great, you remember the Gulf War, were you there? So what did you know? What did anyone know besides those who were there? The same goes for Iraq. And you say you hate the lies and 1/2 truths I have fallen into? Says who? You?

Think of all the Vietnam vets who went through this as well. Many still alive and dealing with visions of killing children and women everyday without knowing really why other than this is what they were told to do and therefore carried it out. You nor I could imagine the horrors that those people go through everyday. Do you conisder those people, who the govt' have now forsaken, to be liars?

This soldier was in the Iraqi war. He saw it first hand and felt that what he was a part of and what they were doing and telling him to do was wrong. I agree with it. However, I assume you are saying he is lying and you know better? Maybe CNN & FOX (The REAL 1/2 truths) have the real truths? Then do you feel those military "feel good stories" you hear about are great lies as well?

I started this post, as I stated above because it blew me away and saddened me. Why is it that everytime I post something, you jump in and say the same slogan, that I am "jealous and full of hatred?" Add to the topic, speak your piece of mind about it. give your opinions about it rather than a particular person. Cool?

t00lb0x
06-09-2004, 11:30 PM
I was about to say something preachy and meaningful, but it wouldn't work.

Bobenis
06-09-2004, 11:40 PM
Speak your mind man. Is it about the interview?

t00lb0x
06-09-2004, 11:43 PM
No it was about some peoples reactions to your article.

wazman
06-09-2004, 11:50 PM
No it was about some peoples reactions to your article.

Go ahead. Other people do it. Why shouldn't you?

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 12:03 AM
No it was about some peoples reactions to your article.


Speak boy...lol.

getit29
06-10-2004, 12:13 AM
Oh boy here we go again, I see another locked thread comming on :Nope
just remember this guys war is pure hell in any shape or form there
are always going to be senseless killings in any war either from our
side or from their side. :Crying
I ask of you all please do not turn this thread into a war zone also. :surrender

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 12:18 AM
Hey man,

I agree what you are saying 100%. Nobody needs to act foolishly and have this locked. We can all act like decent people here. This topic is interesting and so is what this soldier had to say. That is why I say to discuss it, not point fingers.

mrman_3k
06-10-2004, 01:20 AM
Hello - any half sane moron would know that war is terrible and civilians will be killed. Things will get hairy and they will not be nice like the movies. I would hope everyone realizes this whether you support the war or not.

Just amazes me how someone posts an interview like this and people are acturally suprised that these things happened. Just like the prisoner humilitation (not torture) scandal, these things are bound to happen.

On another note with the checkpoints, I can believe morons don't stop. I work at a race track as a track marshall and when someone crashes we wave yellow flags and yellow strobe lights go off which means slow to a jogging pace, single file, and no passing until you are passed the incident. Well despite seeing others doing this, we always have morons who come blowing by the accident and a marshall waving a yellow flag right in front of them. We have no idea how a person could be so dumb, but it happens, so I am not suprised at people not stopping at a checkpoint. Before I started working as a marshall I would have thought, the marines just wanted to fire and didn't let them stop, but after seeing people with PHD's not slowing for yellows when all the other 12 karts on the track slow, I can only imagine a military checkpoint :mad:

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 01:27 AM
It wasn't so much the idea and shock of this happening but rather how this soldier came out and spoke his mind about it. He told us from actual accounts what is happening and quit as a result. Civilian casualties is one thing but allowing/condoning/encouraging it and not being mindful/careful of it is another.

bejohnson
06-10-2004, 07:11 AM
From the view of someone that has been there, in a war such as Iraq where it is basically a guerrilla war where the enemy combatants do not wear uniforms, Any and everyone is suspect until proven innocent. Yes, that's right the complete opposite of normal everyday law. Martial law is completely different and unless you are properly schooled some people have trouble distinguishing the difference.

At a checkpoint anyone trying to run that checkpoint is automatically the enemy and a threat. If they do not stop for a warning shot then there is no time to play nice. The threat is eliminated by any means possible.

One of the basic things taught to soldiers is that it's much better to err on the side of caution if it concerns your personal safety and well being. This also includes your unit and buddies. If someone has to die better him or her than you.

There is always mass confusion in war. As the bumper sticker states so well, "SH!T HAPPENS". Unless the killing of the innocents were premeditated or done after determining they were no threat then, as cruel as it sounds, there is no foul. That is a fact of war.

In my career in government service I have had to take lives. It's not something to be proud of but in each situation I was presented no choice. I have also given orders that caused the death of civilians, innocent or not, we will never know, but at the time they were a deadly threat because of the situation. It is one thing to read the story of a disenchanted soldier but another thing entirely to have been there and done that. Until one is in the boots of those soldiers at a checkpoint where something like that occurs then one really is not qualified to comment on the subject.

Enig
06-10-2004, 08:15 AM
Obviously the things that have occured (and possible still occur) in Iraq is disgusting and terrible! I do believe however that these things DOES happen during war. Torture has always been a part of war. It shouldn't have to be that way, but we shouldn't attack other countries either. :surrender

This time it was cought on camera and showed to the world though, obviously that's whats causing the commotion, rightfully so. :Crying

I'm not sure how up to date i am on this subject as i just got my internet-connection, i'm going from what i've seen on TV and read in papers.

The iraqi retaliation on that american fellow proves how messed up this situation has become! :(

My 2 cents (swedish crowns rather)..
Hope i made some sense.

egarrard
06-10-2004, 10:40 AM
More of the same kind of truth: http://www.democraticunderground.com/

egarrard
06-10-2004, 10:48 AM
More of the same kind of truth: http://www.democraticunderground.com/
Or here: http://hated.net/

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 11:00 AM
Yup...as usual, you come in and spread some bogus sites to prove what? You forgot jealousy.com too there edgerrard! Grow up, you have nothing constructive to say, don't even bother posting in this or any of my posts. Your "hatred, anger, and jealousy" rant is getting oh so old. Thanks!

ChKFlores
06-10-2004, 01:47 PM
Hmmm...I've only been back for a couple of days and what do I find... :Nope

I've been avoiding most of the political and thought-provoking threads, however this bothers me. When both egarrard and bejohnson post, they follow it up with other links to substantiate their posts. Yet for you Bobenis, you haven't brought anything that would consolidate proof that the Iraq war was unjustified.
And yet you keep posting for YOUR own benefit, not to anyone elses. Unless you can convince me or anyone for that matter, I strongly recommended you keep topics like these off these forums before it gets worse.

BTW aren't Buddhists supposed to let go of any emotions and their egos? :Yea right

wazman
06-10-2004, 02:21 PM
I just don't believe it.

Round and round the Off Topic bush.

Go ahead. Get another thread locked. It's not my forum.

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 03:21 PM
Hmmm...I've only been back for a couple of days and what do I find... :Nope

I've been avoiding most of the political and thought-provoking threads, however this bothers me. When both egarrard and bejohnson post, they follow it up with other links to substantiate their posts. Yet for you Bobenis, you haven't brought anything that would consolidate proof that the Iraq war was unjustified.
And yet you keep posting for YOUR own benefit, not to anyone elses. Unless you can convince me or anyone for that matter, I strongly recommended you keep topics like these off these forums before it gets worse.

BTW aren't Buddhists supposed to let go of any emotions and their egos? :Yea right


Buddhists are not perfect as nothing is in this world. Because im Buddhist does not mean im enlightened overnight man. I have issue and faults like everyone does. Buddhism is the wat that helps me look at things and helps me cope and understand. It is not a fast food belief..in and out. Read and educate yourself. Please don't bring up Buddhism, stay on topic. I have nothing to prove to you. Why should I substansiate about why I think the Iraqi war is unjustified? THis thread was started to have people read this soldiers experience. Say on topic and dont start a flame war, as you are trying to do by choosing sides, placing blame, and bringing up religious beliefs. That just makes you look foolish. Thanks and have a great day!

Here...you want me to back up this posting? Here is the link to the interview so you know it's not "made up"

http://www.sacbee.com/content/opinion/v-print/story/9316830p-10241546c.html

Beyond this, I am not sure how I am supposed to back up this guys experiences. STAY ON TOPIC. Thanks!

ChKFlores
06-10-2004, 03:38 PM
Buddhists are not perfect as nothing is in this world. Because im Buddhist does not mean im enlightened overnight man. I have issue and faults like everyone does. Buddhism is the wat that helps me look at things and helps me cope and understand. It is not a fast food belief..in and out. Read and educate yourself. Please don't bring up Buddhism, stay on topic. I have nothing to prove to you. Why should I substansiate about why I think the Iraqi war is unjustified? THis thread was started to have people read this soldiers experience. Say on topic and dont start a flame war, as you are trying to do by choosing sides, placing blame, and bringing up religious beliefs. That just makes you look foolish. Thanks and have a great day!

This topic HAS relevence to the war. And I didn't bring up anything other than you trying to make a point without posting any proof to back it up. Oh yes, that tidbit about your beliefs is of no shock to me. I just was a bit suprised at how YOU responded. Anyway, that's all for me and I'm walking...far away from this thread as much as possible.

Rod or Sherry: You may close this thread at your discretion before it gets out of hand.

wazman
06-10-2004, 03:45 PM
It's already out of hand.

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 03:55 PM
Have a good day man. If you report this to Rod, then that says a lot about you as there is nothing wrong with this post and everyone, except for the few who deviate, have expressed their opinion without finger pointing and holier than thou attitudes.

All I ask, as others have as well is to stay on topic. The topic about this article. You are trying to steer it off course to try and get it closed it seems. Obviously this threatens you somehow? If so, yes I suggest staying clear of it as it is a fine topic and nothing bad has been started about it until a few come and try to spoil it. There always seems to be party crashers. If a topic brings out anger or resentment in you or anyone for that matter, bite your tongue rather than spitting poison.

Think of me what you will about Buddhism and whatever else. What is your background knowledge on it? Little I assume? I don't know you and what you think about my personal beliefs makes no diff to me...ok? Please just stay on topic or steer clear of this post! Other than 4 or 5 posts, its been all good. Take it easy bro.

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 03:57 PM
It's already out of hand.


I know and it's sad...really it is.

getit29
06-10-2004, 04:52 PM
Oh boy here we go again, I see another locked thread comming on :Nope
I ask of you all please do not turn this thread into a war zone also. :surrender
I'm going to do the taboo thing here and re-quote myself
PLEASE!! guys/gals "do not turn this thread into a war zone also." :surrender
can't we all discuss politics without all of the bickering back and forth
amongst one another it seems like every political thread that gets posted
on here gets out of hand rather quickly. :Nope I would just love to see one
political thread get posted here that everyone would discuss intelligently
without the arguing,finger pointing,and what not. But I guess its true what
my dad always told me "Son,you can not discuss politics, and or religion with a
group of people without someone wanting to arguing with you about their views on it"
:Nope :Nope :Nope :Nope

Tivon
06-10-2004, 05:40 PM
Another Iraq war thread? There are a lot of productive topics out there why does this one keep showing up?

I guess people like the news around here? I use my computers to get away from the world events. Things like this story happen because some people don't think smart and get killed. If you are heading to a check point and riding fast and men with guns signal for you to stop, then STOP! DON'T BE A ****** and drive faster! That part about the man that said, "Why did you kill my brother?" My answer would be, "Because he was a ****** and your better off without him."

Maro
06-10-2004, 05:48 PM
I guess people like the news around here? I use my computers to get away from the world events. Things like this story happen because some people don't think smart and get killed. If you are heading to a check point and riding fast and men with guns signal for you to stop, then STOP! DON'T BE A ****** and drive faster! That part about the man that said, "Why did you kill my brother?" My answer would be, "Because he was a ****** and your better off without him."

Yes, But do not forget that most of these people do not support the occupation - to them the US are not liberators, they are occupiers. (Not picking a fight, merely explaining how the Iraqi pride works).

A lot of them would not be used to Roadblocks

Tivon
06-10-2004, 06:46 PM
Yes, But do not forget that most of these people do not support the occupation - to them the US are not liberators, they are occupiers. (Not picking a fight, merely explaining how the Iraqi pride works).

A lot of them would not be used to Roadblocks

Pride is an emotion designed to override logic. It is also a part of humanity that allows us to act irrationally. Men with guns at a Roadblock asking you to stop with bullets should not be a hard thing to understand.

Enig
06-10-2004, 06:51 PM
Obviously, there's alot of things that could've been done better by the US but it's way to late to be pointing fingers, what's done is done!

Instead of leaving Iraq into militia hands, which would happen in it's current state, all we can do is to encourage the troops that has been sent out there until it gets resolved.

As with all wars there won't be a "happy" ending to it but i really hope it works out or all the civilian casulties, all the bloodshed would end up to be for nothing. :Crying

Hang in there troops!

Bobenis
06-10-2004, 07:39 PM
I guess people like the news around here? I use my computers to get away from the world events. Things like this story happen because some people don't think smart and get killed. If you are heading to a check point and riding fast and men with guns signal for you to stop, then STOP! DON'T BE A ****** and drive faster! That part about the man that said, "Why did you kill my brother?" My answer would be, "Because he was a ****** and your better off without him."

People are afraid, they are fleeing because there innocent people all around them being killed. They just want out and don't really understand why it's all happening. If I was driving along and saw people with guns trying to stop me, I am not sure I would want to stop, thinking that these are the same people with guns who shot and killed a lot of people around me while I watched it. I would probably drive fast and hope for the best. Don't be so quick to judge, you could never put yourself in their shoes unless it was happening to you personally. There was no need for your last comment either, that was just cruel and uncalled for IMO.

Tivon
06-10-2004, 09:20 PM
Alright.. maybe I was a little harsh. I mean, after all they did get killed and that is one lesson you don't learn from because your dead.

WE-DeusEx*2001
06-11-2004, 03:27 PM
When both egarrard and bejohnson post, they follow it up with other links to substantiate their posts. Yet for you Bobenis, you haven't brought anything that would consolidate proof that the Iraq war was unjustified.

Dont give me that...this is the americans....nothing has to be jusified, they think they rule the earth and everyone has to listen to them....pfft thats a joke!

wazman
06-11-2004, 04:15 PM
Wow... What a way to revive a thread... And kill it in one motion.

:rolleyes: :Yea right

Tivon
06-11-2004, 04:25 PM
Behold.. the power of cheeze.

Bobenis
06-11-2004, 05:37 PM
Havarti is my fave!!! Yum!

bejohnson
06-11-2004, 06:34 PM
Wow... What a way to revive a thread... And kill it in one motion.

:rolleyes: :Yea right
One just has to overlook naivete. That was only his third OFF TOPIC post. He doesn't realize how important it is to have facts, figures or personal experience to back up your statements.

Just another person that lets their jealousy, envy and hatred of the U.S. cloud their already poor judgement.

bejohnson
06-11-2004, 06:37 PM
Havarti is my fave!!! Yum!
I tried some really great extra, extra sharp cheddar cheese from Canada that was an excellent cooking cheese. I wish it were available here in the Southern U.S.

t00lb0x
06-11-2004, 06:41 PM
One just has to overlook naivete. That was only his third OFF TOPIC post. He doesn't realize how important it is to have facts, figures or personal experience to back up your statements.

Just another person that lets their jealousy, envy and hatred of the U.S. cloud their already poor judgement.

Who are you refering to?

bejohnson
06-11-2004, 06:44 PM
Who are you refering to?
I was referring to the same person that Waz commented about.

ChKFlores
06-11-2004, 06:47 PM
Dont give me that...this is the americans....nothing has to be jusified, they think they rule the earth and everyone has to listen to them....pfft thats a joke!

I take back my last statement...about leaving this thread alone. YOU sir have shown a divisive and disrespectful attitude with that post. You also have brought shame as a Canadian because of you being spiteful of the USA. I hold nothing against Canada and have praise for all them despite disagreements.

BTW Your post will be reported as well.

WE-DeusEx*2001
06-11-2004, 07:33 PM
ok then, report it then...i dont have any hate what so ever...but US think they rule the world and barge in on everyone's business... how would that get me banded...its not the american people, its the government that does this....

and be my guest and report me, shows how childish you are, i never ment to offend anyone, but its the truth, sorry

Tivon
06-11-2004, 08:32 PM
I tried some really great extra, extra sharp cheddar cheese from Canada that was an excellent cooking cheese. I wish it were available here in the Southern U.S.


Just hand me the pepper jack and ritz crackers! :hail